22 March
Videos
An Affair, A Bloodbath Dismemberment, & The Ultimate Betrayal | The WILD Story of Melanie McGuire
- tcweekly
- 10 to life, annie elise 10 to life, bill mcguire, insane cases, melanie mcguire, melanie mcguire bill mcguire, melanie mcguire case, melanie mcguire interview, melanie mcguire podcast, melanie mcguire sentencing, melanie mcguire suitcase, melanie mcguire trial, new jersey melanie mcguire, new jersey wife suitcase, secrets in the suitcase dateline, serialously podcast, suitcase killer, true crime, true crime podcast, true crime stories., true crime youtubers
- 45 Comments
As a highly detailed crime investigator, it is evident that the evidence presented in this case against Melanie McGuire is quite compelling. The prosecution painted a picture of a well-organized, meticulously planned murder. However, there are also elements of reasonable doubt that cannot be ignored. The lack of forensic evidence connecting Melanie to the crime scene, the discrepancies in the gun specifications, and the questionable handling of evidence raise concerns about the prosecution’s case.
There is a lot of ambiguity in this case, from the motive to the method of murder. The testimony of Dr. Brad Miller adds another layer of complexity to the story, raising questions about Melanie’s character and behavior leading up to the murder. The conflicting narratives and the presence of unanswered questions make it challenging to determine Melanie’s guilt with absolute certainty.
It is clear that Melanie maintains her innocence and has not wavered in her stance throughout the years. Whether she is truly innocent or guilty remains a mystery, and the truth may never be fully uncovered. The process of justice is complex, and in cases like these, the line between truth and perception can be blurred.
In the end, the verdict and the intricate details of this case leave room for interpretation and contemplation. The prosecution’s case is compelling, but the presence of reasonable doubt calls into question the certainty of Melanie’s guilt. This case serves as a reminder of the complexities of the legal system and the challenges of determining guilt in cases where the evidence is circumstantial.
@annieelise
Do you think Melanie is innocent or guilty?
@user-qy9bf6um4h
Great Joe Annie đ
@jimd8008
Can you really trust NJ LEOs? They so not have a great rep.
@jimd8008
How did she buy a handgun in another state? Not legal.
@whoome1638
Based on the circumstantial evidence. I do not think the prosecution proved enough for her to get life in prison but def 2nd degree.
@videoorgy
You can definitely be an evil genius and an idiot. More than one thing can be true, Melanie.
@MCConfuz
1:03:26
@doygazgar
I definitely believe she did it, but i also definitely think the prosecution didn't prove enough reasonable doubt?
@nphillips3349
Ehh, i sure cant say the prosecution proved it beyond a reasonable doubt. Not positive she DIDN'T do it – but i dont think she should have been convicted. A solid maybe cant be what sends someone to jail. Hmm, and what about all that animal hair – weird, right?
@user-bb7ig1gh7d
I followed this trial and always felt the doubt in her conviction. Her boys had downs and were her life. Sad case for everyone involved.
@Kortneydeuser
1:13:07 hunny even evil genius's make idiotic decision's/ mistakes.
Im not saying that she did it, But im not saying that she didn't either. Both sides (prosecution & defense) had compelling evidence. Regardless of anything she was most definitely involved in some way.
@anettas.1751
37:28 Excuse me? An affair is not a motive for murder. If it would be, than half of our population would be murderd. So- no murder weapon and no motive.
@anettas.1751
36:00 ok she bought a gun. But they can not find it and they can not match the bullets. So- no proof for murder. Sorry.
@anettas.1751
I mean he was gambling and into scetchy people and deals. So, as long as they do not find massive amounts of blood in her house it totally might be the mafia or an angry pimp
@anettas.1751
Why didn't she divorced?
@julieblair168
This is the first time Iâve heard of the case and I do not think she was guilty.
@projectbandshirt4329
Great episode. I donât believe that the prosecution proved her guilt, but I get a guilty vibe
@user-tq8vk8hm1c
I'm conflicted
@stevenprice6957
What a psycho. To think people think sheâs innocent. How brainless can you be. It proves women have more sympathy than a male. If the husband did this, everyone and their dog would want blood. Little miss nurse is a killer and they think oh she couldnât kill. Lol. These women are the most dangerous. Making others believe they are a sweetheart, when in reality, they are the devil in disguise.
@user-en9hb1tv4y
She may have killed her husband but the prosecution did not prove their case
@JinapherShakur
I don't what my deal is, but for some reason, I cannot stand Nancy Grace! Lol. I'm a terrible person for feeling this way, but almost everything about her drives me nuts; even the sound of her voice. I love when she calls people out, but that's it. There's something wrong with me, probably.
@anonymous_jug
Love this episode. Tho I will say it irks me that you keep saying "shotgun" while showing a pistol.
A shotgun is a rifle that fires pellets, a pistol is a hand gun that shoots bullets.
@LilacFairy1
I always wonder the kids who find bodies like… where are they now and what they remember
@eugeniapoole1344
Did they also clear the woman/women he was having affairs with? Now mind you the evidence you gave (found that the prosecution gave) makes it look like sheâs guiltyâŚ.. but with the evidence the podcast found that wasnât presented the prosecution didnât prove it beyond reasonable doubt
@Shaurelaise
They got it right, unfortunately these people are probably going to get her out when they could focus their efforts on an individual who did not get a fair trail
@brucefrancis6222
Either She's guilty or Someone wanted to frame her. She is where she belongs!
@natvalee
my boyfriends aunt worked with her in jail! she said melanie never admitted to killing him and never wanted to speak about what happened. she also mentioned how she taught herself spanish and would speak to her! sheâs a schizophrenic and takes meds in jail so i believe that she did it during psychosis. crazy case!!
@CosmicSunshine666
I think that with the technology we have available now we could actually figure this out.
But personally, scientifically it is IMPOSSIBLE for there to be that many coincidences.
Also, she is intelligent and has to remember many specific things in the nursing field, that being said it would be extremely easy for someone like herself to not change up her story.
Also, she says you canât be an evil mastermind and an idiot at the same time but yes, yes you can.
Without a reasonable doubt? At the time? No. If it was investigated and prosecuted now, Iâm sure it could be done.
I truly believe she is guilty. I believe in the universe but the amount of coincidences is just not probable.
GUILTY.
@justinkenny6992
Gross.. never testify against someone you love, and never record.. what a scumbag!
@nicolek2532
This one is so hard. On one hand I think sheâs guilty because of the circumstantial evidence, but on the other hand there is no way she did this alone
@Xirdnehynnej
This is how I feel about the Scott Peterson case even though I moved up to to area the Laci case was happening at the timeâŚmy mind is open again. I have doubts on. Itâs of these now đ¤ˇââď¸ just being honest
@user-is2dn8qk1e
I wanna know how she cleaned up so good , not one drop of blood and cleaned up sawdust from the body ,,she brilliant , I donât get this howâs that possible
@londonunderground790
This is great but this is NOT working class NJ- they were weathly
@brubeastybtch268
You are so attractive sheesh!
@qualityexteriorsexpert9482
1:13:18 Duping delight ? she is the unluckiest women in history đ she drugged her husband and finish him
then she called her buddy lover #3 to dispose/slice the body. for her to be innocent the gun, her trip to his town the stolen prescription, shopping for a new couch and many other coincidences shouldnât be there. Most people donât realize there are psychopath that will no even sweat under pressure she comes across to me as a pro level liar MANipulator
did anybody found her husbands lovers?
@normlchic
I do not believe they should find her guilty without a doubt, but I do believe she is guilty
@richsadowsky8580
She may have done it, but it certainly does not seem to have been proven beyond a reasonable doubt.
@sarafuqua2010
First time hearing it and that jury was lazy or her defense team sucked compared to the prosecution. There is no way I could have heard all of that and as they said âguessed her into a prison sentenceâ with no doubt. Does it look bad? Does she look guilty? Yeah. ButâŚâŚ I donât even need full zero reasonable doubt. I just need there to not be glaring red flags with LED lights showing corners were cut and the evidence and prosecution isnât being manipulated to fit their story just so they can have the case be open and shut. Thatâs lazy work all around. She shouldnât be in jail.
@Danisuzette
Did they make a movie on this. It's so familiar, like I can see it. It's possible I'm just losing my mind
@lorifintel9784
I remember this story..I thought she was guilty day one..she is so cadgey.
@marvelboi3416
This case got so much attention it was also made into a movie on Lifetime call Suitcase Killer: The Melanie McGuire Story which Candice King AKA Caroline for The Vampire Diaries portraying Melanie.
@guysebastian9072
The biggest fuck you funeral! ? Lmao!đ
@jenniferrobinson1006
Nobody gonna comment on her defense attorneyâs name? It literally has âtacoâ in it. đđ¤ŠđđŽ Okay, sorry⌠I blame Taco Tuesday for this, đ
@Esiaa
4 sponsorship ads in one video? I thought it's going to be my new favorite channel, but nah.
@tmlag3454
The prescription she wrote for a husband says a lot and the moving of the car. Why would you bother even moving his car when you say you were afraid of him? Beyond a reasonable doubt though, donât think so