Delving deep into the dark world of a missing girl, Jonelle Matthews – a once promising young student who vanished without a trace from her own home. As we sip our coffee, we analyze the puzzling pieces of this unsolved mystery, uncovering the chilling truth behind her disappearance. The case remains open, with new leads emerging decades later, as the search for justice continues in the shadows of uncertainty.
@amybenson9317
I live in Penn Yan, Ny only a couple minutes away from ROC! I am so excited to hear that a podcaster is local around me! I love listening to your YouTube channel ❤
@Tammygotsushi
She's married?!?! Shucks there goes my dream. 😂 Just kidding. Hi Adam 👋!!!
@RainbowAmbitions
This man would get along well with Michael Turney
@dorcamercado4608
For sure he did this…. all by his own words and actions….😢 and specific say so!
@AWholeBeew
Lesbian here. My gay background on my Chromebook is a very sultry-looking Leliana from Dragon Age: Inquisition. 😂
@DragonQueen78
As a Christian, I am really very annoyed with all of these crazy psychopathic people calling themselves "born again Christians". I am sure you know this but to Stephanie and all reading there are good Christians out there who are peaceful and loving people. Not child murdering weirdos. 🤦♀️
@ashna4779
This story is every parents nightmare. Or well mine. 😢.
Side note I love your glasses
@corinacoady2183
Aw Stephanie I am so sorry you are not feeling well… I hope you feel better soon
@sherryparis5647
Actions speak louder than words. He really injected himself into the case.
@JESSEXTO
That was not glowing, that was sweat 💀
@loreleidotcom
I love your content and never leave comments but I wanted to start with that! As far as Steve Pankey, I do think you're a little quick to assume that he's culpable in Jonelle's death. It is strongly circumstantial, but after hearing all the talking about the case he did and the way he conducted himself in general….I've known people like that. People who aren't playing with a full deck and strongly desire the spotlight- both of which I believe describe Steve Pankey- will latch on to anything sensational and it will impact them heavily (especially as a nobody in a small town) and they'll desire so strongly to be in on the action that the sensational event never leaves their mind. A lot of his statements that seem to indicate guilt fit perfectly with that archetype of someone who's just a busybody nobody who ended up fixated on something that wasn't related to them besides that they were physically located close to the event. Anecdotally, I've seen people who had Steve Pankey vibes latch on to events they had no connection to, good or bad, just because it puts them in the spotlight for a minute. He's said sus things but you said yourself "He's talking constantly" and none of the things he's said indicate inside information about the case that wasn't made public. He has said a lot of things that implicate him, but he's also seemed so desperate to be somehow linked to the case since it's the big hot issue for his small town, it makes sense that it would be at the front of his mind when he had a death in the family. I think adding himself to the list of people the police should investigate was just another one of those petty attempts for recognition.
@danielleschiazza6172
@Stephanie Harlowe how do i get to your merch store??? Do u still have the "don't come for me" tee shirts?????
@danielleschiazza6172
One thing i cannot stand is people who obsess over religion and God and go to church all of the time and constantly bring God into everything and so on and so on, yet they are the most horrible, sick, ugly, disgusting monsters! This man really had some nerve sitting in church, calling people false prophets, when he had just raped and murdered a child.
@dawngrimes7361
Steve just gives creepy vibes
@lindahowell1282
Your makeup looks beautiful ❤️ i love watching because you deep dive brings all the information to us
@SjofnBM1989
The way he keeps refering to the s–ual assault he commited as a "date r–pe" to downplay the severity of what he did is making my blood boil
@sunnisunflower522
I love your commentary , your my fave !
@girlonamission1685
He obviously did it and he is bread crumbing LE.
@kellysue3566
Explaining how things change in a community after a kidnapping is so true. A little boy aj in Illinois in my county (Mchenry) was murdered by his parents and buried by the fox lake park. It really changed my perspective of my area. Just recently too a 14 year old boy died in Richmond a town literally so close to me who's mom had fetnyal in the house. Its so sad how things like this happen.
@CE-jl1lv
I live in Greeley, it’s still not safe and the police department is still a effin’ joke
@goodbher9244
Me: turning around to see my rainbow flag behind me.
"Oh shit- I have a gay-background."
@tompagano9015
I stumbled onto your site looking for information on Echoes of Darkness. Excellent review of that True Crime story including discussion of the unanswered questions . I like it that you give your opinion and don’t pontificate like a Redheaded Nancy Obnoxious Grace. Plus you do your own work. I would like you to follow-up on the Matthew’s case even though it might be a short follow-up .
@bb-ih9hg
Is this irl Colin Robinson? He has to be the most boring and draining guy I've ever listened to, and a menace of annoyance and weirdo shit to everyone who is involved with him.
@early.autumn.summer
Greeley has a large Hispanic population and a large community of immigrants, and white supremacy is obviously an issue in policing, but for this man to try and spin this against greely bc he has made up beef with the police is actually insane
@Jenny.MG82
Watching it again and I am baffled at Steve talking one Portion of Bull after another
@Blip-pk6kf
51:42 yea cause how u remember to a T what u were doing 30+ years ago
@janettemcgregor4100
Stephanie please stop playing with your hair it's so distracting when I'm trying to focus on your narration. 😢
@NatalieRenee-sv4qi
Omg i
Am swetty too
@NatalieRenee-sv4qi
Yas love you and love it song
@lyndsaylundy9406
Comment is 2 years too late but a lot of the time the police do their job and the prosecutors cut deals and let them out. I never hear prosecutors thrown into the mix and they have equal amount of responsibility.
@ducksinarowpatience3670
I remember thinking the, Mason family was going to get me when i was in kindergarten. 😢
@daisymoonsavage5040
Is there an update on this story?
@jessicamckinley8732
I am also from Rochester NY! I moved to another state back in 2015 but I sure do miss the lilac fest, park ave fest, and most importantly, WEGMANS!!
@darlaabbott9040
Omg Stephanie im like 45 mins from if that lol i live in hornell
@charlenesinger5872
His smile is crooked, so is his nose . Creepy